Pir Pesar

When I watched the movie, felt the same as the time when I was reading Brothers Karamazov. They show how family becomes a microcosm of society's larger moral and existential struggles. At heart, both The Old Bachelor and The Brothers Karamazov are about:The inheritance of sin and guilt across generations. Men trapped between obedience, rebellion, and longing for redemption. The dangers of unchecked power, whether paternal, social, or internal.

Oktay Baraheniseems to have intentionally borrowed not just themes but also stylistic techniques from Dostoevsky, particularly The Brothers Karamazov, the house in the movie send you back to the Fyodor's house.

A new outlook for a persian movie. Director all does his best and a great scenario performed. The casting is great leila hatami a great Iranian actress acting well and pourshirazi is just too good despite his character's mental complications. Btw I think this movie will achieve international praises. Just like what asghar farhadi did to iran cinema.

The Old Bachelor," directed by Oktay Barahani, was for me more than just a typical drama. With Hassan Pourshirazi's outstanding performance as Gholam Bastani, the film skillfully portrays the archetype of the "Puer Aeternus" or "Eternal Youth." This character, despite his age, remains emotionally stunted, refusing to embrace the responsibilities of adulthood.

This interpretation is reinforced by Gholam's own pivotal dialogue: "A man whose life has no rules or order, even if he grows old, will remain an old boy and never truly grow up!" Furthermore, one can observe echoes of "Dionysus," the god of ecstasy and liberation, within Gholam Bastani, which perfectly complements the "Eternal Youth" aspect of his character. This is a profound and thought-provoking film that delves into the psychological layers of humanity.

I stayed with the film until the end. As we were leaving the cinema, most people seemed to be praising it. But I couldn't shake the feeling that something was off-I wasn't satisfied. I asked myself: beyond all its claims, what kind of experience did this film actually give me?

Pirpesar, directed by Oktay Baraheni, is a long film that manages to keep the viewer engaged-not through the strength of its storytelling, but by relying on familiar cinematic devices like romantic rivalry and erotic suggestion that cleverly manipulate the audience's attention. The film tries to appear profound and impactful, but the message it claims to carry is no more compelling than its flawed narrative execution.

Much of the film is weighed down by unnecessary and poorly constructed scenes, and several performances are noticeably weak. The director's limited understanding of key characters results in portrayals that feel shallow or misguided. The film's conceptual contradictions do not stem from its literary references-such as The Brothers Karamazov or Shahnameh-but from weak authorship and a lack of narrative coherence. While one or two actors do shine, overall this is not a successful film. It's a work that, more than anything else, seems crafted to satisfy the pseudo-intellectual viewer who's looking for symbolic depth where little truly exists.

The Old Boy is one of those rare cinematic experiences that captivates the viewer from its very first moments. With a cohesive narrative, well-crafted dialogue, and deep character development, this film not only delivers a satisfying movie experience, but it lingers in the viewer's mind long after the credits roll.

The film's greatest strength lies in its flawless combination of storytelling, acting, and visual design. The visual effects are stunning-not only do they enhance the scenes, but they help define the tone of the film. The meticulous production design and lighting distinguish The Old Boy from many domestic and even international productions.

The performances are exceptional. The cast is perfectly chosen, and each actor brings a unique psychological depth to their character. The ensemble's chemistry is clearly felt, and it keeps the story grounded in believability at every moment.

Despite having a relatively classic narrative structure, the film surprises the audience with creative and powerful moments. Its key plot points are smartly placed and paced without any rush, creating a balanced rhythm that feels neither too slow nor too fast.

Ultimately, The Old Boy is a successful example of cinema that appeals to both mainstream audiences and artistic sensibilities. It deserves to be watched, analyzed, and praised.