Testigo de la mafia

I see lots of good reviews having good points and people downvoting them, perhaps because of the lack of information on the life of Sammy the Bull and Gotti.

This is a good film. It's not Goodfellas, it's not Casino, it's not all the major mafia movies, because this one doesn't rely so much on the violence they did, not even compared with Gotti since it presents us with a different view of the scene, more from the perspective of Sammy.

Everyone talks about the cast. Yes, an amazing cast, most of them being later cast in The Sopranos (Michael Imperioli, Tony Sirico, Vincent Pastore, Lenny Venito, Kathrine Narducci, Frankie Valli, Arthur J. Nascarella, Richard Bright, John Cenatiempo, Steven Randazzo, Paul Borghese, Sam Coppola, Garry Pastore) others in Goodfellas (Michael Imperioli, Vincent Pastore, Tony Sirico, Johnny Williams, Debi Mazar), others in Gotti (Vincent Pastore, Toni Sirico, Frank Vincent) and even from The Godfather (Richard Bright, Abe Vigoda) and Frank Vincent who played in Sopranos, Goodfellas, Casino and Gotti. They also played in other mafia movies ass well (A Bronx Tale, The Alto Knights, The Irishman, American Gangster, Capone, Live by Night, Boardwalk Empire, Tulsa King, The Family and many more) . We also got actors who played in the HBO amazing series OZ (namely Kirk Acevedo, Richard Bright and Peter Appel) and a lot of them who played in Law & Order.

Now that I made your head spin with all the names of the actors (no, not all, just made a selection) lets talk about the movie itself.

And the first thing I want to specify is that the movie is NOT based on Sammy's book, but on court records, FBI transcripts and news reports, as Wikipedia states (maybe not the best source). But that doesn't make it less true, the movie is actually quite on point with the real events and portrays them well, without the need of much Hollywood drama. Sometimes, reality beats film.

Now the comparison with Gotti (1996). Armand Assante made a great job portraying Gotti, but so did Tom Sizemore. However, between Nicholas Turturro and William Forsythe portraying Sammy, I definitely prefer Turturro as he gets closer to the real Sammy, even though here he seems to be a little too soft compared to the real guy. As for Gotti, he wasn't that smart in reality as he is depicted in both of these movies. Also, it's more realistic than HBO's Gotti. Both are great movies however and it's hard for me to decide which one's better.

I really don't understand the small rating (6.7) on IMDb. We got a well documented movie with a great cast, good story, good lines, good cinematography and everything, and it gets 6.7 rating, while The Last Don (1997) has a rating of 7.1, The Many Saints of Newark has 6.3, The Valachi Papers has 6.4, Live by Night has 6.4 and last but not least, Tulsa King has 8.0. These productions were awful compared to Witness to the Mob and they had very little to do with reality (except Valachi Papers). I guess people like the Hollywood drama more than reality, or are not very knowledgeable about the reality of the Cosa Nostra. But even as a movie production, leaving aside the reality checks, it's still very well produced. I just don't get it.

I wish I wrote this review right after I watched it or while watching it, since there's a lot going on in the movie but I can't go again watching a 3 hour movie and taking notes. You just have to see it and make your own opinion.

This movie is based on the true story of "Sammy the Bull" Gravano, a self-confessed killer who helps prosecute Mafia boss John Gotti, in exchange for immunity. Yes, the acting is a bit wooden, and the script full of cliches, but it's an interesting study of a real life Mafia case - definitely worth a look, but certainly not a classic.

This movie is tragically miscasted. And though many reviewers claim that this movie is closer to the truth than HBO's Gotti was, it is inferior in every way.

It all starts with Turturro. Someone here claims he looks the part of Gravano, but that just ain't true. He's far too dark skinned, and though he has Italian ancestors he has always looked more Mexican to me. It also has to do with his role in NYPD Blue. Turturro doesn't play the part of a made mafia man. He always looks timid, shy and a bit anxious (same for his role in NYPD Blue). The supporting cast is full with the usual suspects you see in mafia films, and most have got their known roles in the Sopranos. But that also makes it a problem, a supporting cast that clearly overshadows the lead role just doesn't work. I don't know about Tom Sizemore, I love the actor, and he does a decent job. But Assante was better, he really embodied Gotti.

It all doesn't work. And the story may be closer to the truth. But remember that 'truth' is a strange concept in this context. The truth is based on a single testimony and some investigative work. In my opinion movie makers have some freedom in interpreting such truths for their work. HBO's Gotti just works much better.

This is got to be Tom Sizemore's greatest acting performance. Sizemore as John Gotti was absolutely brilliant it couldn't be any more perfect than that. I was blown away by this film, but Tom Sizemore blew the doors off in this film he clearly stole the show.

And this movie was excellent. The acting, the plot, the story line was spot on. Loved it.

All in all Witness to the Mob is superior to the HBO fairy tale called Gotti - but the former fails at what the latter did right: the portrayal of Sammy Gravano. Strangely, it seems that most filmmakers think they need a hero or at least a resemblance thereof. In HBO's Gotti it was Gotti, a charismatic, smart leader with comprehensible morals, whose downfall was the egoism of his underlings. In WttM, Sammy the Bull is portrayed as a misunderstood, dutiful voice of reason and overall goody two-shoes. Both portrayals are as far from the truth as it gets.

WttM shows Gotti the way he was: an egomaniacal braggart with delusions of grandeur. (I am at a loss as to how some folks can criticize Sizemore's take on Gotti which unlike Assante's is very close to the original.) A blend of these two movies would yield *the* authoritative adaptation of the subject. In direct comparison, though, WttM takes less liberties with the story, which is why I vastly prefer it over HBO's version.

On its own WttM is a very enjoyable LCN movie - even more so for those who are interested in the subject, provided they can generously overlook the factual inaccuracies.