PUNTUACIÓN EN IMDb
6,1/10
295
TU PUNTUACIÓN
Añade un argumento en tu idiomaAn examination of the aftermath of Desert Storm and how servicemen and women were affected by it medically.An examination of the aftermath of Desert Storm and how servicemen and women were affected by it medically.An examination of the aftermath of Desert Storm and how servicemen and women were affected by it medically.
- Dirección
- Guión
- Reparto principal
- Premios
- 1 premio y 6 nominaciones en total
Reseñas destacadas
Just as some people said that agent orange was not real, some so say that gulf syndrome is not real. But this movie, although it does take some dramatic license, starts with the real stories of real veterans who have illnesses which they relate to their service in the gulf war, be it a "syndrom" or not. Regardless of what you believe, this movie is very thought provoking and motivates the audience to investigate on their own the truth behind the stories of the many veterans whose stories are told in this movie. I recommend that you see it. It is beautifully acted and filmed and Ted Dansen and Marg Helenberger are particularly impressive.
A solid, perhaps sombre treatment of a literally toxic subject that many would, and did, try to ignore and brush under the carpet. The cast in the main are workmanlike and there's even a couple of recognisable faces like Ted Danson from Friends as Jim Tuite, and the substantial Brian Denney playing Sen. Donald Riegle. The screenplay and story arc are a kind of homage to All the President's Men, with its own Deepthroat in the shadows, stacks of paperwork, political stonewalling, etc and there's more than a bit of recreated Washington committee hearings, but these do lend some authenticity to the matter and provide the best bits as far as I'm concerned.... Okay it is a TV movie but I did have a problem with some of the production values in particular the sound architecture which was very strange and flat, and perhaps it was just my TV I don't know but the sound effects and the schmaltzy soundtrack did seem to overwhelm and indeed drown out some of the dialogue. As for the human drama of those affected, it was nice to have a human face on some of the people involved in this catastrophe. I note one reviewer was upset that the whole matter of the rectitude of the war itself wasn't dealt with, and indeed that might be a point that one draws from this. But of course that was not the remit of this particular movie and it strains to be largely pro-veteran, and patriotic, but it is cynical about politicians, and we never hear from President Bush. The "ghost of Vietnam" never leaves the story from start to the epilogue. The main arguement seems to be that one needs to create a future battlefield that's a lot more safe for the American soldier at least.
"One of the most controversial international stories of last decade of XX century was made alive in this provocative movie that while searching for hidden truth about mysterious syndrome of Gulf War on fascinating way shows what did more than 100.000 brave U.S soldiers get for their loyalty to their country.
Chris Small (Matt Keeslar) is a model soldier who went through finest training, but nothing could prepare him for the horrors of "Desert Storm" action. Fiery clouds on the horizon, deterrent alarms, decomposing body of dead fellow soldiers are some of the memories he brought home to Memphis, where he was gratefully welcomed by his friends and family. Despite his return, he is not happy because he came back sick and changed. Movie is about struggle of his family and some other people to find out and show the truth to the nation.
This excellent movie reveals hidden facts of that big military operation, concentrating on important and cover-up story about real causes of health issues of large number of U.S. Gulf War veterans. Producer Rod Holcomb took this itchy and hard subject and transfered it to the screen, giving amazingly detailed answers to questions many wouldn't dare to ask. Excellent rolls of Ted Danson, Jeniffer Jason Leigh and Matt Keeslar, who did a great job featuring proud u.s. soldier. " *movie description by Croatian RTL, translated by me
Chris Small (Matt Keeslar) is a model soldier who went through finest training, but nothing could prepare him for the horrors of "Desert Storm" action. Fiery clouds on the horizon, deterrent alarms, decomposing body of dead fellow soldiers are some of the memories he brought home to Memphis, where he was gratefully welcomed by his friends and family. Despite his return, he is not happy because he came back sick and changed. Movie is about struggle of his family and some other people to find out and show the truth to the nation.
This excellent movie reveals hidden facts of that big military operation, concentrating on important and cover-up story about real causes of health issues of large number of U.S. Gulf War veterans. Producer Rod Holcomb took this itchy and hard subject and transfered it to the screen, giving amazingly detailed answers to questions many wouldn't dare to ask. Excellent rolls of Ted Danson, Jeniffer Jason Leigh and Matt Keeslar, who did a great job featuring proud u.s. soldier. " *movie description by Croatian RTL, translated by me
6=G=
"Thanks of a Grateful Nation" is a docudrama which attempts to tell the tale of Gulf War Syndrome. A Showtime commercial journeyman drama which muddles fact with fiction in the interest of entertainment, "Thanks..." runs too long at three hours, slogs around in woebegone soapy sentimentality with fictional subplots, is fraught with overtones of paranoia, and doesn't do justice to the interests and people it pretends to support. Those interested in GWS can find the real deal easily on the Inet. Pass on this one.
What this movie fails from answering is how wrong this war is (and most US wars recently made only to get some oil).
How many innocent civilian casualties there has been, how many lives perished and how blatantly stupid the perpetrators are.
So, let me ask you - if American soldier kills women and children apart from enemy, its OK, but if government accidentally kills their own forces by deadly chemicals while killing many civilians as well, it is not? Your logic fails, gentleman.
I'll give it 5 for the solid performance and 1 to everything else, 3 in total.
How many innocent civilian casualties there has been, how many lives perished and how blatantly stupid the perpetrators are.
So, let me ask you - if American soldier kills women and children apart from enemy, its OK, but if government accidentally kills their own forces by deadly chemicals while killing many civilians as well, it is not? Your logic fails, gentleman.
I'll give it 5 for the solid performance and 1 to everything else, 3 in total.
Selecciones populares
Inicia sesión para calificar y añadir a tu lista para recibir recomendaciones personalizadas
Detalles
- Fecha de lanzamiento
- Países de origen
- Idioma
- Títulos en diferentes países
- Wojna w Zatoce
- Localizaciones del rodaje
- Empresas productoras
- Ver más compañías en los créditos en IMDbPro
Contribuir a esta página
Sugerir un cambio o añadir el contenido que falta