Aligarh

Though the story is short and simple but never maker you feel board while watching. One of the most important element of the movie is the acting by the lead actorss ( Manoj sir and Rajkumar Rao ) which will never let you expectation down with the movie. Overall movie was a nice and offered a very serious and not much discussed topic in a brilliant way.

A must see flick! Bajpai has delivered a restrained performance and yet he brings out the innocence and purity of Prof. Siras's soul. The pain and anguish can be seen in his eyes and his attire and body language for a 64 yr man was just too good. this is method acting at its peak! this is a performance even Jack Nicholson, tom hanks or a Daniel Day Lewis would be proud of. his performance will haunt you for long. the direction and screenplay is also brilliant and the way in which the subject was handle has to be appreciated. his soliloquy while listening to Lata Mangeshkar is brilliant. The court scenes and argument were well written and filmed. Rajkumar Rao as journalist has also done justice to his role. the pace has been kept deliberately a little which allows you to get to the skin of characters. the ending though sad leaves an ever lasting impression. All in all one of the great movies of our time!

Aligarh was chosen as the opening film of the Mumbai Film Festival and I went to see it wondering if the story, based on real life events, had been sanitized for the screen. To the screenplay writer and director's credit it has not. The sad story of 64 year old Professor Sirus, who was suspended and systematically harassed by Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) for having gay sex with a cycle-rickshaw driver, has been told here in all its poignancy. In it's time, it was a big case for gay rights in India, but Sirus was a frustratingly difficult protagonist, an unattractive personage unwillingly to face the media, unwilling to identify as gay, unable to see the larger issues at stake. Manoj Bajpayee does an excellent job in the complex role of the unhappy Sirus, with all its contradictions. He's shown drinking excessively every night, listening to maudlin Lata Mangeshkar songs. I don't know if Rajkumar Rao is based on a real-life character, but he plays a crucial role as the reporter who tries to draw Sirus out of his shell. He only party succeeds. For one, Sirus was very proud of his position as professor of Marathi at AMU and he was very loyal to AMU itself. He tells Rao he the victim of campus politics because he was promoted to chair the linguistics department, provoking petty jealousies. People knew he was homosexual and used it against him, sending two goons to break into his house to film him having sex. What followed was a downward spiral, but Hansal Mehta somehow manages to keep things from getting too depressing. One interesting scene has the now famous Professor Sirus being invited to a sophisticated gay gathering while in the city, where his newfound fans insist he sing a Marathi song. He does so, rather badly, and then collapses drunk.

Aligarh picks a take on all known issues and problems in the society regarding homosexuality. The best part is the decency of the storyline in which it has been structured. It has been edited well and flows respectfully. It could've been a wonder if the gripping nature would've been maintained. But often it digresses from the plot and disconnects the viewer.

Wonderfully directed by Hansal Mehta, he takes his sweet time in detailing irrelevant things. Many times it makes sense but only if editing is proper. Nevertheless, the effort is fantastic in getting the whole plot together.

Rajkummar Rao is just not stopping to improve himself with every movie. He has the sense of maintaining the required body language all through. Manoj Bajpayee underplayed a lot too much but delivered a good performance.

Overall, a decent and a respectful take on homosexuality but could've been a wonder if gripping nature would've been maintained.

Reviewing this after the Supreme Court's historic judgement of decriminalizing homosexuality- September 2018

I was waiting for an opportune time to watch this film and could find none better than the day after this historic judgement.

This film is based on the real life story of Dr Siras, a professor of Aligarh Muslim University. He was hounded out of his job, due to being 'caught' with another man in the privacy of his home! He fought this injustice in court and his job was restored by the judiciary, but he was forced to commit suicide or even murdered. The way the film captures his story is beautiful. It will force any thinking human being to introspect on his or her prejudices against anyone.

Manoj Bajpayee as Prof Siras is immense; he carries the film on his shoulders and shows just how beautiful a person the professor was. He was a simple man, content in doing his job, and really good at his work. The way Bajpayee manages to flesh the character out is what the essence of good acting is. The dignity of his character and his vulnerability will make you cry as to how our heartless society treated such a person. Rajkumar Rao as the reporter who manages to strike a rapport with the professor, has done his job. There could have been a little less focus on his backstory as it does not add a lot to the film.

So all in all, this is a film to experience and hopefully to introspect on where we as a society have been going wrong. People such as Siras are meant to be respected and treasured; and not hounded; and the day that happens will mean that we as a society have arrived.