murpz

The original version of this story, done on the radio Gunsmoke, was a masterpiece of gritty, bleak and realistic storytelling. As other reviewers have suggested, it's a little out of place in the TV version.

Furthermore, Bill Conrad's version of Marshal Dillon with his gravelly voice works much better with the often gloomy and dark story lines that were much more common with the radio show than the more tame television Gunsmoke. Beyond that, radio's reliance on sound effects rather than pictures add a haunting element with the howling winds and the noises in the pitchfork scene.

This episode is good, and worth watching... but do yourself a favor and give the radio version of "The Cabin" a listen!

This is an awesome, awesome miniseries (or 12 hour movie, depending how you look at it). The title "Into the West" might make you think this is another movie about the US and its expansion westward, settling the wild west. You'd be very wrong. This movie focuses heavily on the experience of the people who were already there, and what the invasion meant to them and their culture. Spielberg has used his incredible talents to produce a powerful chronicle of an epic clash of civilizations, and the profoundness of what was lost. It's also a good movie to watch, with top notch acting and cinematography. I caught the last episode of this when it was on TV, and when I saw it available on DVD, I immediately bought it so I could see the whole thing. I'm very satisfied with my purchase!

While I find the ethical message of this movie to be somewhat offensive, endorsing theocratic fascism, I can get past that and still enjoy a good work of fiction. What I can't get past though is the horrible, stiff, forced, wooden cue-card "acting" and the unbelievable plot holes. The only reason I would tell anyone to watch this stinker is to see just how bad acting can be. I suspect even most Christians (which I am not) would find this movie repulsively bad.