Culpa Tuya - Deine Schuld

If you seek a well-written review, I recommend Kkaterhyne's. Their critique closely aligns with my personal experience of the movie. I highly recommend reading the book, as it is significantly superior to the film adaptation. Why alter the original story for the movie? The ending failed to evoke the same emotional impact as the book. In the book, Michael served as her therapist, possessing the ability to manipulate her. Where is his brother? The portrayal of Nick's mother felt forced and lacked authenticity. While the passionate scenes were present, they lacked emotional resonance. I cannot pinpoint the exact reason, but it almost felt as though I was watching a different movie, one that lacked the familiarity and charm of the original. The music in this adaptation also deviated from the original, contributing to the sense of disconnection. The first movie was a resounding success and garnered immense popularity, while this one feels like a low-budget production.

"My Fault" (Culpa Mia) was a different film. It was the story of Noah becoming part of a rich family when her mother married William Leister. Her mother was finally happy after years of abuse from Jonas. It was a funny movie with romantic moments and of course the teen parties and the car racing. Guess it was a one hit wonder for the writer.

"Your Fault" (Culpa Tuya) is a poor sequel. It's not funny, the romance is up and down and it's too talky with a lot of drama. "My Fault" moved quickly, "Your Fault" drags. It's at least 30 minutes too long, edit out the boring parts and at 90 minutes it would be better. I'm dreading what the third part of the trilogy will look like.

I was waiting for this movie after watching the 1st, it wasn't the greatest movie ever made but I love cheesy, cliché movies and it was one of them, but this one....

It felt rushed, but also full of nothing, and I was looking up people opinions and apparently so many things are missing from the books or were completely different, honestly it's not worth the watch if you ask me, don't know why the friends are now getting screen time when in the first one they only showed them when noah or nick was on screen and it was better that way because as movie you have to come every second counts but they didn't get the memo with one.

What did I just watch? It was worse than a B movie. It looked like something a school class would throw together. How this is possible when Culpa Mia was so good is beyond me. It almost seems like a purposeful destruction of a story. Culpa Mia was young adult, a bit tacky and fast paced but the soundtrack, the acting and the way it was cut was incredible. What in the world happened here? Same actors and director. Looks like they had a week to shoot it and a couple of amateurs just threw it together. And why would you score it with a weird mix of classic music all the way through. Unfortunately I could go on and on... I hope the creators will explain what happened. Did the funding get pulled? Or was there just no more story to tell?

The books are really bad so I'm actually impressed the first movie in the trilogy was so good. But boy oh boy they should have stopped after the first movie. This movie was almost impossible to get through. Now I understand the painful expressions on the two main characters in the few promo interviews they've given prior to the release. This is the type of movie that can ruin your career. Jesus, the story was so bad. They should have rewritten the manuscript and moved away from the books if they wanted to do a sequel.

Nothing good to say. Not one good scene in all the movie.

What could've been a tight and engaging story is painfully stretched into a trilogy for no real reason. This movie drags its plot out with unnecessary filler and subplots that add nothing to the overall narrative. Instead of building real tension or developing characters, it feels like the movie is just wasting time, leaving you more annoyed than entertained. The visuals are decent, and the cast tries their best, but the pacing is all over the place, and the story lacks any real depth.

It's like getting a fancy dish with no substance, all style, no substance. By the time it finally ends, you're just relieved it's over.