IMDb-BEWERTUNG
6,6/10
3261
IHRE BEWERTUNG
Füge eine Handlung in deiner Sprache hinzuWhen a gifted 9-year-old girl, who works in a garment factory, is offered a once-in-a-lifetime chance to attend school, she is forced to make a heart-wrenching decision that will determine h... Alles lesenWhen a gifted 9-year-old girl, who works in a garment factory, is offered a once-in-a-lifetime chance to attend school, she is forced to make a heart-wrenching decision that will determine her and her sister's fate.When a gifted 9-year-old girl, who works in a garment factory, is offered a once-in-a-lifetime chance to attend school, she is forced to make a heart-wrenching decision that will determine her and her sister's fate.
- Regie
- Drehbuch
- Hauptbesetzung
- Für 1 Oscar nominiert
- 5 Gewinne & 1 Nominierung insgesamt
Empfohlene Bewertungen
Anuja has been attracting a lot of attention recently due to its Oscar shortlisting and Priyanka Chopra's fame. As expected, it's a heart-wrenching story that reflects the struggle of a 9-year-old girl who is not even mature enough to make those choices. Perhaps that uncertainty is what makes it special.
The short film tells the story of a nine-year-old girl, Anuja (Sajda Pathan), who works in a factory. When questioned about her age by a school teacher who wants to take the opportunity to help her get an education, she claims that she is 14. Despite lying to his face, the teacher still gives her the choice to come back to school and take her exam. Anuja has a caring sister, Palak (Ananya Shanbhag), who is the only person Anuja might listen to.
Palak wants Anuja to become educated and build a bright future that she couldn't achieve for herself, which is also what their mother desired. Yet, she is unable to persuade Anuja to go and take the exam, but who knows if Anuja might listen to her. As promised to her sister, Anuja has to go to the exam, albeit reluctantly. At the same time, the factory owner offers her a job after noticing her remarkable talent for math. Will Anuja be able to make a choice at such a young age?
Anuja ends abruptly, feeling somewhat incomplete, but that uncertainty about Anuja's character actually makes it a complete film. It runs for 20-21 minutes and, therefore, feels short, which may explain why I couldn't feel any significant impact. Yet, it is absorbing enough to make you think about it for a moment.
The main reason for this age is that the story resonates with millions of girls across the world. They are too small to make choices, and maybe that's why they have remained backward and poor for years. Some girls don't even get that rare chance, and those who do fail to understand what it means. There is not much special about it other than mirroring some bitter facts of society.
Sajda Pathan was natural, and it is not a typical act that can be judged as a "performance." She is not even an actor, so it would be unfair to assess her acting. It's all about her screen presence, and the same goes for Ananya Shanbhag. Nagesh Bhosle was fine as the factory owner, and Gulshan Walia was decent in the two or three frames in which he appears. The rest of the cast hardly appears enough to be noticed.
Adam Graves' simple formula of human emotions without dramatic conflicts makes it a decent watch. There is a lot of hype surrounding this project in India, so I'd like to say, "cool down, guys. There is nothing out there for you to hype." Watch Anuja just to understand the problem that has existed for years, and many of us are already familiar with it. We have had many independent shorts and documentaries about the same. It's just that one "burning" moment at the end that might stay with you. You can skip the rest of the show, but what's there to skip in 20 minutes?
The short film tells the story of a nine-year-old girl, Anuja (Sajda Pathan), who works in a factory. When questioned about her age by a school teacher who wants to take the opportunity to help her get an education, she claims that she is 14. Despite lying to his face, the teacher still gives her the choice to come back to school and take her exam. Anuja has a caring sister, Palak (Ananya Shanbhag), who is the only person Anuja might listen to.
Palak wants Anuja to become educated and build a bright future that she couldn't achieve for herself, which is also what their mother desired. Yet, she is unable to persuade Anuja to go and take the exam, but who knows if Anuja might listen to her. As promised to her sister, Anuja has to go to the exam, albeit reluctantly. At the same time, the factory owner offers her a job after noticing her remarkable talent for math. Will Anuja be able to make a choice at such a young age?
Anuja ends abruptly, feeling somewhat incomplete, but that uncertainty about Anuja's character actually makes it a complete film. It runs for 20-21 minutes and, therefore, feels short, which may explain why I couldn't feel any significant impact. Yet, it is absorbing enough to make you think about it for a moment.
The main reason for this age is that the story resonates with millions of girls across the world. They are too small to make choices, and maybe that's why they have remained backward and poor for years. Some girls don't even get that rare chance, and those who do fail to understand what it means. There is not much special about it other than mirroring some bitter facts of society.
Sajda Pathan was natural, and it is not a typical act that can be judged as a "performance." She is not even an actor, so it would be unfair to assess her acting. It's all about her screen presence, and the same goes for Ananya Shanbhag. Nagesh Bhosle was fine as the factory owner, and Gulshan Walia was decent in the two or three frames in which he appears. The rest of the cast hardly appears enough to be noticed.
Adam Graves' simple formula of human emotions without dramatic conflicts makes it a decent watch. There is a lot of hype surrounding this project in India, so I'd like to say, "cool down, guys. There is nothing out there for you to hype." Watch Anuja just to understand the problem that has existed for years, and many of us are already familiar with it. We have had many independent shorts and documentaries about the same. It's just that one "burning" moment at the end that might stay with you. You can skip the rest of the show, but what's there to skip in 20 minutes?
The short film seems even shorter than it is, because it is so breathtaking. The girls are adorable and their life situation heartfelt. I needed to see this, this part of the world is not unknown to me, but it isn't easy to visualise and understand it. Not even sure I ever really can? It shows true love between sisters and their happiness, while working and living in low standard jobs and housing.
The opportunity offered to the youngest, to step out of her current situation might seem logical to every adult, but it isn't for the young child. Influenced by her employer and the love for her sister makes her decision to leave not easy.
The cliffhangers in the end of the film are necessary, but tough to handle. I want to know what will happen to both the sisters, but I will have ot imagine it for myself. And that power. That makes this movie impact the one who is watching. We have to know, we have to understand, and that is something we have to do by watching actively, and contemplate by ourselves. Dive into the mind of the orphin, what will she do?
The opportunity offered to the youngest, to step out of her current situation might seem logical to every adult, but it isn't for the young child. Influenced by her employer and the love for her sister makes her decision to leave not easy.
The cliffhangers in the end of the film are necessary, but tough to handle. I want to know what will happen to both the sisters, but I will have ot imagine it for myself. And that power. That makes this movie impact the one who is watching. We have to know, we have to understand, and that is something we have to do by watching actively, and contemplate by ourselves. Dive into the mind of the orphin, what will she do?
This short story revolves around two young girls who stay in Indian slums and try to earn their livelihood by working in cloth factories. They try to fight out of this poverty by choosing between education and food (an unfortunate choice that millions face in India) but are confused in this game of instant gratification that penalizes short-term hunger over long-term hunger and poverty.
I expected the movie to have a storyline, either inspiring or sad. But it does not have a close-ended storyline, neither joyous nor sad. It just en-cashes the problems of India, and the producers (big-name producers like Guneet Monga and Priyanka Chopra Jonas) just showcase a short "day-in-the-life" video in a desperate attempt to win some awards.
I expected the movie to have a storyline, either inspiring or sad. But it does not have a close-ended storyline, neither joyous nor sad. It just en-cashes the problems of India, and the producers (big-name producers like Guneet Monga and Priyanka Chopra Jonas) just showcase a short "day-in-the-life" video in a desperate attempt to win some awards.
I heard that a short film from India made the final nominations for oscars 2025 so I had to give it a try and after watching I don't know what to say I just gave an 8 just cause of the topic of the movie and it's post credit scene
I mean the makers presented nothing new they just showed the reality on the big screen
The ending was open ended which I liked it was like saying whatever she chooses it is going to be a wrong decision good creative choice
FAVOURITE CHARACTER :: elder sister her struggles were touching FAVOURITE MOMENT :: Anuja asking her sister in the middle of the night will he come with her.
FAVOURITE CHARACTER :: elder sister her struggles were touching FAVOURITE MOMENT :: Anuja asking her sister in the middle of the night will he come with her.
No story. No content.
Writer & Director Adam Graves has done a cheap impression of Slumdog Millionaire (2008).
This film is just an another attempt to portray India's poverty in the west and win some brownies in the form of awards!
An extremely insincere, phoney and hollow attempt at filmmaking.
The two kids (Sajda Parhan and Ananya Shanbag) have acted well.
Everything else is crap ridden with clichés, tropes and stereotyping.
Btw which theater in India screens a film like Naya Daur (1957) these days? The film maker is so out of touch with modern India!
The film looks like a propaganda film for Salaam Baalak Trust.
Don't fall the publicity rhetoric. The film is not worth your time!
How did it even make it to the Oscars? I wonder!
Writer & Director Adam Graves has done a cheap impression of Slumdog Millionaire (2008).
This film is just an another attempt to portray India's poverty in the west and win some brownies in the form of awards!
An extremely insincere, phoney and hollow attempt at filmmaking.
The two kids (Sajda Parhan and Ananya Shanbag) have acted well.
Everything else is crap ridden with clichés, tropes and stereotyping.
Btw which theater in India screens a film like Naya Daur (1957) these days? The film maker is so out of touch with modern India!
The film looks like a propaganda film for Salaam Baalak Trust.
Don't fall the publicity rhetoric. The film is not worth your time!
How did it even make it to the Oscars? I wonder!
Wusstest du schon
- Crazy CreditsThe title doesn't appear until the 5-minute mark.
Top-Auswahl
Melde dich zum Bewerten an und greife auf die Watchlist für personalisierte Empfehlungen zu.
Details
- Laufzeit22 Minuten
- Farbe
- Seitenverhältnis
- 2.35 : 1
Zu dieser Seite beitragen
Bearbeitung vorschlagen oder fehlenden Inhalt hinzufügen