A Lot Like Christmas

6.2 stars.

Clay, a regional marketing director of a garden supply store (sorta like Home Depot or Lowe's supply center) is sent to utilize his skills in Hudson Springs, a town that doesn't necessarily respond to that sort of big business. The town is full of people who enjoy small town ideals and good old fashioned Christmas spirit. Jessica and her brother run the Roberts Farm, a Christmas tree farm in this town and they are now dealing with this rival big store that competes with their sales of trees, plants, and gardening supplies. Jessica likes Clay but is unaware he represents the superstore. He does his best to be cryptic and keep that information from her, because they are attracted to each other, and he knows it will ruin their chances at something more. When the truth is revealed it's a very big explosion of anger and seething disdain.

Her hatred for him is laughable if I'm being honest. I don't think this is a realistic response and do people do this in the real world? The whole first half of the film is the two of them barely getting acquainted and the second half comprises the war she wages on him and his company. The last two minutes is nice, otherwise this is a bland movie with a very limited plot. I had a difficult time getting through this movie and it didn't feel 'A Lot Like Christmas'. The title, is clever. They own a Christmas tree lot, ha ha. They wasted some good actors, cinematography, and music on a dead end plot.

Tidbit of trivia: the Roberts farm has an old red pickup truck used in another movie by the same actor, but in the other movie it was his delivery truck for his bakery business. About every 5 Hallmark movies, I see a house, building, street, vehicle, costume, or other object that is reused. I suppose Hallmark could do worse.

He is adorable but she ruins it. I finally had to stop watching it over half way through. Casting makes a huge difference and Maggie Lawson was terrible in this part!

I thought this was going to be yet another big-bad-executive-comes-to-the-small-town-to-ruin -it holiday movie. But in A Lot Like Christmas, the Big Bad executive is Clay Moore, who is one of those guys who everybody likes. He comes into town from Manhattan looking for a Starbucks. He asks these two elderly men that are sitting on a bench and they tell him that of course there is no Starbucks in that small little town, but there is a local diner. After getting the directions, Clay asked them if they wanted anything. They give him a big order which Clay remembers! Clay is just a nice guy who can talk to anybody about anything, buys random strangers breakfast, and helps older women with their groceries, etc ect etc

There were so many cool things about this movie. I loved the fake falling snow. The mayor was an African American woman. There was thankfully just two small town traditions. Too many can ruin a movie.

Jessica and Clay meet when she hits him with a tree she is cutting down on her family's farm. Oh and one of the things I look for in all of these Hallmarkish romances is a dance scene btw hero and heroine. After Jessica declares Clay her enemy, they have this we're-not-dancing-together dance to Jingle Bells, which was sooooo cute!!!!

And did I mention how much I loved Clay--with his lilac shirts and purple suits!

Having been watching more Christmas films for a while now, since 2019 but becoming more regular each year. Namely those from Hallmark and Lifetime, with very variable success, with some UPTV and ION films too. Only got into the newly formed GAC Family films fairly recently, and like Hallmark, Lifetime etc. There are good films, some bad ones and some in between. Have liked Maggie Lawson and Christopher Russell in other things, though their work in acting and filmography are hit and miss.

'A Lot Like Christmas' is one of the in between efforts for GAC, and while it is a good representation of Russell Lawson has been a lot better in other films of hers. 'A Lot Like Christmas' was more or less what was expected. It didn't exceed expectations, but it is a long way from a waste of potential. Instead it sounded like potentially it would be a pleasant enough diversion with a number of good things and a few big drawbacks, and 'A Lot Like Christmas' turned out to be pretty much exactly that.

Russell gives a very sincere and charming performance in his role, and his character up to a point comes over as very amiable. Lawson has moments of perky charm. The supporting cast do well, despite their characters being stock and ones seen many times in similar films.

It looks good, lovely scenery and slickly shot. The music is pleasant and fits tonally enough, the placement also not getting too much.

For my tastes, Lawson on the whole tries too hard and her character goes overboard on the too eager to please side. Her chemistry with Russell isn't really there, pretty lacklustre, especially later on when the conflict kicks in and when Lawson's acting becomes particularly overdone. Also lost a lot of respect for Clay when his secret came out, a secret that was handled in a contrived and predictable way and a very mean spirited one. Which is a big reason as to why the ending didn't ring true. The conflict that it causes felt very forced.

The dialogue tends to be flat and stilted and also rather soapy in the final act. The story is one of those doing nothing new with familiar ground ones, so the predictability is excessive and nothing here feels fleshed out enough. The pacing tends to drag and the charm, light hearted-ness and heart are missing, especially later on. It is easy to predict what the ending is, but part of me really didn't want it to happen and that it would do something different but it went down the too easily resolved route.

Watchable but nothing special. 5/10.

I am a fan of Maggie Lawson and her energy and upbeat personality. I was very pleased to see that Clay didn't march in oozing with arrogance and privilege. The character needs to be confident, almost to the point of overconfidence, but Russell didn't overdo it. Clay is actually a pretty nice guy and there is no mean and antagonistic confrontation with Jessica like so many rom/coms seem to think are necessary.

Unless the story has a special sentimental draw, I want upbeat in my Christmas movies. Tension is necessary, but this movie spends a great deal of screen time showing how small businesses and small towns are being ruined by big corporate ones. It's a fact of life. It's not an unusual story angle especially in Christmas movies, but there was too much of it in this case.

This movie diverts from the formula by having Clay's secret revealed around the half way point. This makes it possible to take an unusual tack through the rest of the movie, but unfortunately it was annoying. "It's not personal, it's business" immediately disqualifies Clay as any kind of romantic interest given Jessica's circumstances. Perhaps the appropriate response to him is "It's not business, it's my entire life". Clay has no clue. The ruined the rest of the movie for me and despite it was the only way to end this type of movie, I couldn't believe what happened.