Nerdy Prudes Must Die

I was recommended this comedy-horror-musical on my YouTube feed and was unknowingly thrown back into the elaborate and captivating town of Hatchetfield, a town of obscenity, unpredictability, and musicality. The plot line for this show is fascinating and, although predictable at times, keeps the perfect amount of artistic parody and dedication to making heartfelt work. After some references, I remembered watching The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals years back and was even more intrigued by the storyline. Team Starkid have been making absolute bangers since 2009 with A Very Potter Musical and they have great works and stories being told.

As someone who has only seen clips of the rest of the Starkid shows this was the best piece of theatre i've seen in ages! The energy, comedy, and VOCALS where just top tier.

Grace/Angela and Max/Will were just unbelievably hilarious. I cant wait to sit and watch every other show because i feel like ive stepped into the weirdest cinematic universe out there, and i loved every second of it.

This was like Rocky Horror meets Glee meets a nightmare on elm street and every song, scene, and piece of dialogue just made the whole thing better and better.

Truly couldnt pick out a moment i didnt like.

StarKid started strong in 2009 with A Very Potter Musical and has remained consistently great for 15 years while getting even more polished.

This show stands on its own and is constantly enjoyable, but the more of StarKid's prior Hatchetfield content you've watched, the better this show is. There are running gags, recurring characters, in-jokes, and an entire lore surrounding all the weird stuff that happens in Hatchetfield.

And all their stuff is freely available on their YT channel.

If you are considering checking out this movie, you might want to consider watching The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals first.

Though I genuinely love this musical so much, I was inspired to write a review as a direct retaliation to the 2/10 review that is among the written ones.

This guy gave it a TWO OUT OF TEN because he claimed he was BORED? And then complained that the musical didn't have movie-like production quality and it was "too much like a theater production." Where do you get off PAUL. It's a goddamn musical, which you didn't even know before you started watching it, and said you would've, "opted out of watching" if you'd known beforehand. Hey, man, THEN TURN OFF THE DAMN SHOW.

Oh, wait... he did! He didn't even finish TWENTY FIVE MINUTES of the show before turning it off!! Why are you writing a review???? You don't belong here!!!! You didn't even WATCH IT.

I have never written a review but my jaw literally dropped when reading that review. This is all jokes.

I had never heard about the 2023 movie "Nerdy Prudes Must Die" prior to sitting down to watch it here in 2025. And had I known it was a musical, I would not have opted to watch it. Regardless, I sat down to watch it, expecting it to be a horror comedy.

"Nerdy Prudes Must Die" failed to entertain me, and I found it amazingly difficult to get submerged into the narrative, as it was just like watching a theater play. Everything happened on the one and only same screen. Yeah, that didn't really appeal to me. Sure, I do like some musicals, such as "The Rocky Horror Picture Show" and "Grease", but they were made like proper movies, not like a theater show. Writers Matt Lang and Nick Lang didn't entertain me with this 2023 production.

Needless to say that I was not familiar with a single performer on the cast list. The performances were fair enough, despite the fact that the script failed to capture my interest.

This was not my cup of tea, and I ended up giving up on "Nerdy Prudes Must Die" 25 minutes into the ordeal. By then I was just bored senseless. And I am never returning to finish watching this, as 25 minutes out of 146 minutes was more than enough torture to send me spiraling into boredom.

My rating of directors Nick Lang and Curt Mega's 2023 musical "Nerdy Prudes Must Die" lands on a generous two out of ten stars.