In late 2005, Target department stores began accepting pre-orders for a sequel titled Leisure Suit Larry 2: Island Tale (working title - Leisure Suit Larry: Cocoa Butter). Magna Cum Laude cast members Tim Dadabo and Melanie Harrison, among others, had recorded voice-overs for the sequel, developed by High Voltage Software for the PC, PlayStation, Xbox, and PlayStation Portable systems. The storyline for the game was to take a shipwrecked Larry Lovage to the San Areolas Islands. However, the game was canceled before completion.
According to producer Joshua VanVeld, "Larry Laffer was the only true inspiration for Larry Lovage. We wanted Larry Lovage to seem like the true nephew of the great Larry, just updated. So Larry Lovage is stuck in the 1980s, where his uncle was stuck in the 70s."
The uncredited character models are: Christina Kyriakakis (Tilly), Ally Lane (Zena Zepplins), Karen Lynn (Luba), Tina Melone (Suzi), Jamie Quin (Zanna), Amy Schleser (Barbara Jo), Mianda Watts (Bilzarbra), Alison Weder (Sally Mae).
In the H.O.Z. sorority house, there is a composite on the wall, honoring former members from 1986 to 1987. The images are of women from the original EGA Leisure Suit Larry games. Clockwise from top left are: Fawn (LSL1), The Hooker (LSL1), Suzi Cheatem (LSL3), Cherry (LSL3), Barbara Bimbo (LSL2), Tawni (LSL3), Passionate Patti (LSL3), Eve (LSL2), Faith (LSL1) and Bambi (LSL3).
The first Leisure Suit Larry game to incorporate motion capture technology.