Mit Büchse und Colt

Spectacular Western in medium budget focusing a Wagon Train of emigrants to Oregon. As the valiant emigrants epitomise the bravery of the early West , at least as Hollywood saw it .It is set in 1846, a New York Herald journalist , Fred MacMurray , joins an Oregon Trail wagon train to verify if is truth about undercover troops sent by President Polk posing as settlers in order to reclaim Oregon for US.

This American Western has a turbulent and mighty history , some of which is told in this story , along with some attractive Folk songs .Here is a panoramic view of the American West , concerning the dangerous travels, risked adventures, hazards, including Indian attacks , chavalry charges , Indian assaults on Fort Laramie and anything else .It is an epic movie photographed in Technicolor , but adding ridiculous Matte-painting .For the most part , it is a pretty ordinary drama about settling to the West , adding a brief intrigue about an uncovered Army official and a journalist played by Fred MacMurray .Particularly here stands out the motley group of actors, and special mention for a big main and support cast. Fred MacMurray plays a Newspaperman who falls for a beautiful Indian girl played by Gloria Hendry , while William Bishop falls for the attractive Nina Shipman, John Carradine as a settleman who spends the limited water by watering his plants , Henry Hull as the Wagonmaster Guide , John Dierkes as the nasty pro-Indian traitor , the elderly Elizabeth Patterson , James Bell, among others .

Aside from being predictable and regular story , the picture has a few pluses, such as Cinematography by Kay Norton , though being necessary a perfect remastering, as well as spectacular action scenes as Indians lay siege and attack Fort Laramie. Charming and catching musical score by Paul Dunlap , including wonderful songs as Ballad of the Oregon Trail, and , Never Alone composed by Paul Dunlap and Lyrics by Charles Devlan . The motion picture was regularly directed by Gene Fowler Jr. He was a prolífic producer , director and especially film editor . Directing some movies as Gang War , Showdown at Boot Hill , The Rebel Set , Here come the Jets ,I married a monster from Outer Space , I Was a Teenage Werewolf , and various episodes of famous TV series as Rawhide, The Waltons, Caliber 44 , Perry Mason , Assignment Underwater , Man with a Camara, Gunsmoke , among others. Rating 5/10 .Mediocre but passable .

Can't help but think this version of 'The Oregon Trail' was put together hurriedly to cash in on the enormous popularity of the TV series 'Wagon Train' with Ward Bond? Having said that, it's always a pleasure to watch Fred MacMurray, one of the movies most versatile stars, his stock in trade was comedy, but he was equally effective in drama, or rugged outdoor films, like this was supposed to be, and at 6'3" and that great physique, I think he fits the bill! First time I'd seen that gorgeous blonde, Nina Shipman, can't help but think Fred should have finished up with her instead of the Indian maiden? Fun to see some of the screens great old character actors like Henry Hull and John Carradine, plus Elizabeth Patterson, who played the Mother of Fred and Bing Crosby in 1938's 'Sing You Sinners', she would have been in her 80's here, and still great! Not a great film by any means, but enjoyable enough if your a fan of the stars, and I am! Sadly William Bishop died the same year the film was released, 1959!

By 1959, TV westerns had begun to replace the Hollywood B-western so there's the distinct feeling that "The Oregon Trail" -- despite its color and widescreen -- really isn't needed. Certainly there's no passion or style apparent in the film's making. It's more a case of everyone just going through the motions and collecting a paycheck.

Things begin unpromisingly with a scene involving President Polk in Washington D.C. This scene tries to give the story a historical context but it's on the dull and talky side. This is followed by another lax scene in which dapper, man-about-town reporter, Fred MacMurray, is assigned to go west on a wagon train and write a story for his newspaper. Finally, as MacMurray arrives in Westport, Missouri -- the eastern start of the Oregon Trail -- things begin rolling. They do so in a conventional way, however, and the entire trek west is filled with the usual situations: troubling encounters with Indians, dry water holes, tensions among the folk on the wagon train, an unexpected rain storm, a funeral service by the side of the trail, a settler protecting his apple-tree seedlings, etc. The use of stock shots and indoor sets hamper the effects of many of these scenes and there's no real villain to conflict with Fred MacMurray. There's also no tension about his mission since he makes no effort to hide it and the possible romantic- triangle involving him and William Bishop and Nina Shipman never takes form. Instead, MacMurray is implausibly paired with Gloria Talbott who appears fairly late in the proceedings.

Action builds toward a last-reel Indian attack which now seems quite "politically incorrect." (The "half-breed" Indian girl implausibly says: "It is because of this, I renounce my people.") Perhaps the only notable thing about "The Oregon Trail" is the scene in which Indians capture Fred MacMurray, strip off his shirt, and stake him out to die. (For a man in his early 50s, MacMurray looks pretty good bare-chested!) While TV westerns often staged these stake-outs, they're not all that common in the movies, and who'd believe one of them would "star" an actor about to get a career boost by playing in Disney comedies?!

Any of you out there think Fred MacMurray wouldn't be convincing in a covered wagon pioneering the Oregon Trail? You're not the only one, which is why he doesn't play a cowboy in the movie. He plays a city reporter, on an assignment to write about the Oregon Trail, so he tags along with a wagon trail, led by the gruff and grizzly, racoon-cap wearing, gravely-voiced Henry Hull. The versatile character actor is real tough in this one, not at all like the softie he played in Boys Town. He stands up to Indians, mounts a horse with no difficulty, and knows how to tackle anything from a water shortage to rattlesnakes.

Fred is the lead, though, working undercover to find secret bad guys, wooing women, and learning how to cope with dust in his trousers and sleeping on the dirt. If you're a fan, you'll like seeing him in this City Slickers-esque movie. Keep in mind it's not a comedy, though. There are some tense situations, trigger-happy grumps, and violin strings playing whenever Granny Elizabeth Patterson says she knows she'll make it through the entire ride. John Carradine portrays Johnny Appleseed, and there's a particularly sad scene when his trees get attacked. Personally, I found this movie too sad to be enjoyable. You might want to try the Lewis and Clark biopic The Far Horizons instead.

I was enjoyed to see this pretty little western again. Colourful, action packed, with interesting and deep searched characters. Real good picture indeed.

But there is one thing that petrified me literally.I was torn to pieces when the Indian girl, who was in love with Mac Murray and saved him from the Indian warrior, says that she disowns her own people - because of his ferocity, after the ending slaughter. SHAME ON HER !!!

I have never heard such a crap, sorry nonsense, in a western before; and I have already seen thousands of them since I was a kid !!!

I am an Indian lover, and proud of that. I am also sad and angry when I think about all that white people did to the Indian nation. They wiped them out. For their land only. They nearly killed them all with bullets, hunger, plagues, alcohol, misery in reservation - even now...

So, in short, when I hear that kind of nonsense from a character in a movie, particularly an Indian one, i prefer think about something else or switch my TV set off.

But, let's be fair, except for that, "Oregon trail" is nevertheless a good western.