Noch einmal mit Gefühl

Two films came out in the same year based upon plays by Harry Kurnitz, directed by Stanley Donen and starring Yul Brynner. The less said about 'Surprise Package' the better as it is too ghastly even to contemplate. This one is quite an improvement although once again Brynner, this time playing an orchestral conductor as opposed to a gangster, proves that he is utterly devoid of a sense of comedy. His portrayal of egomania is convincing. The redeeming feature of the other one was Noel Coward whilst here it is Kay Kendall. Her vivacity is intoxicating and her comedy timing impeccable. The scene where she plays the harp for the orchestra trustees is a comic gem. There are some excellent one-liners and it looks fantastic courtesy of lighting cameraman Georges Perinal and production designer Alexandre Trauner. Sadly this film represents the final bow for the glorious and incomparable Kay Kendall who died before its release.

Unlike Saratoga with Jean Harlow where you can easily tell that the star was in some kind of distress while making the film, there is absolutely no trace of any of ill health in Kay Kendall's sprightly and last performance. A kind Providence left her just as I'm sure she would want to have been remembered by her many fans in Once More With Feeling.

The film is adapted from the original play by Harry Kurnitz which ran for 263 performances in the 1958-59 season on Broadway. Kurnitz was a screenwriter of long standing with an impressive list of credits so I'm sure he had no trouble getting this play sold to the screen and wisely with the proviso he adapt it for film. The play was produced on Broadway by Martin Gabel as a star vehicle for his wife Arlene Francis in the part that Kendall had on screen. Her husband was Joseph Cotten and the part of their manager was played by Walter Matthau.

Cotten's role was taken by Yul Brynner as the egotistical symphony conductor with his wife, talented harp prodigy Kendall. There's is a stormy relationship and Brynner's got a roving eye. It roves to Shirley Anne Field who turns out to be not a child prodigy of 12, but a shapely young thing of 21. Too good to resist for Brynner, but the last straw for Kendall.

The problem is that in the world of classical music, she's the attraction, him they put up with. Manager Gregory Ratoff finds that Brynner's best solo offer is Fargo, North Dakota, quite a come down from the London Symphony.

After this the film and play start looking a whole lot like Twentieth Century. That doesn't mean it isn't good, just not truly original. Brynner and Kendall play well off each other. In the supporting cast I like Mervyn Johns as the director of the Liverpool symphony with whom Brynner is campaigning for a position with or without Kendall. In the midst of the classical music, he who has the Liverpool Symphony deficit as a tax write off for his canned goods firm demands The Stars and Stripes Forever in all concerts and played with piccolo players standing. Is there any other way? Will the Philistine get his way?

Stanley Donen directed Once More With Feeling at a nice and bright clip and he had his own little joke in the credits. Donen who directed several MGM musicals both alone and in collaboration with Gene Kelly had scores by Romberg, Gershwin, etc. Now of course he's dealing with Wagner, Beethoven, Tschaikovsky, and of course John Philip Sousa.

And this review is dedicated to Kay Kendall, who left a nice body of work in her short life that ended at 33. And to my sister Nancy who left us at 34. Both are sorely missed.

I finally found a copy of this which I had not seen since it came out. I still found it wonderfully funny and vintage Kendall. Perhaps the reason why this movie has not survived in the public arena is that it deals with a couple "living in sin" who have to marry in order to divorce after a 7 or 8-year liaison in order to satisfy public morality. Seems unbelievable now, but can think of no other reason, other than perhaps Kay Kendall's estate is difficult about her films.

Another Kendall movie which seems to be unattainable is "Simon and Laura" with Peter Finch. This film takes a rather cynical look at the TV industry, viewer loyalty, and "soaps" and these aspects might be a reason for its suppression. Since writing this, it has just been released on DVD in the U.K.(March 2007)

This is a latter-day example of the "screwball" comedies of the 1930s, and has standout performances from Yul Brynner, Kay Kendall, and Gregory Ratoff. Beautifully filmed, gorgeous sets, great comic emsemble, and is LONG LONG overdue for re-release on video. Please!! I want to own a copy of this film for my library. This is one movie I could watch again every week.

It is a shame that this film has not been released on video. It is a witty observation of the classical music world with Yul Brynner playing the part of a temperamental orchestra conductor. It was also Kay Kendall's last film - she was fatally ill when she made it and died shortly after it was finished. She was a marvelous comedienne and was a great foil for Yul Brynner. Every classical music buff should see this film!