Vazante

Pacing, plotting, and storytelling clearly aren't this director's forte. I don't know what her forte is, but it's definitely not making watchable films. This travesty jumps around wildly from scene to scene, never letting you know if it's the same instant or weeks or months later. The characters' motivations are inscrutable and never explored, and what little information we do get is supplied through forced, clunky exposition between characters. Truly terrible.

Good photography. Good performances. Predictable script. Completely boring rhythm.

Very good portrait of the life of enslaved Africans (both their habits and their suffering) and the decaying slaver society in Brazil, shown in a perhaps too sluggish pace but with an amazing and careful sober low-contrast black & white cinematography (besides rich sounds which transport espectator to that farm in Minas Gerais). Many social issues are discussed as the actual background, such as impoverishment of small farmers, patriarchy, low-age marriage for girls, dark-skinned free workers who repressed black slaves, varied and naturalized violences against black enslaved people (including sexual one), African religion and languages, people considered as animals (what cinematography captures in many beautiful and strong scenes)... As director explained, slavery oppression is often portrayed in Hollywood as something made by psychopath individual minds, but that cruelty was much more systhemic, in the level of state, deep in the ground of society structure. Against most critiques, I agree with her and I believe she was able to sgow that. In the middle of the movie, film's focus narrows from a more general exploration to the passage from childhood to teenage of a white girl in that harsh environment. Probably it was not the most interesting among available stories she could have developed. Though, it was a valid one, anyway.

The only positive is good photography. After that nothing is good. Very boring rhythm, the story jumps around and it does not explore anything deeply. Painful to watch.

This visual arresting film is about 1800s colonial life in central Brazil depicting the harsh life of slavery plus a forbidden love story and vengeance. Its cast produces wonderful performances like the main protagonist, "Antonio" played by Adriano Carvalho.

The story unfolds as "Antonio" tends to his settlement, a place of numerous slaves and marries his recently deceased wife's teen niece, "Beatriz" (played tenderly by Luana Nastas). The strength of this story is the focus on gender, since its female characters dominate this film. From the master's maternal household to the slave women used for sexual affairs and labor for Antonio, this cast of diverse women characters solidify the storytelling.

This film is met with visceral imagery as it was shot entirely in black and white. Thomas's depiction of plantation work and visual references of Minas Gerais (known for its mining history) follows great Brazilian photographic traditions. There is almost no music soundtrack (although Brazilian legendary musician, Tom Ze has a track in the film) letting the viewer take in sounds from the landscape of birds chirping to food cooking throughout the house.