Buy new:
Save with Used - Very Good

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet or computer – no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Follow the author
OK
Weapons of Choice: World War II With a Startling Twist: 1 (Axis of Time) Paperback – 1 Jun. 2004
Purchase options and add-ons
The impossible has spawned the unthinkable. A military experiment in the year 2021has thrust an American-led multinational armada back to 1942, right into the middle of the U.S. naval task force speeding toward Midway Atoll--and what was to be the most spectacular U.S. triumph of the entire war.
Thousands died in the chaos, but the ripples had only begun. For these veterans of Pearl Harbor--led by Admirals Nimitz, Halsey, and Spruance--have never seen a helicopter, or a satellite link, or a nuclear weapon. And they've never encountered an African American colonel or a British naval commander who was a woman and half-Pakistani. While they embrace the armada's awesome firepower, they may find the twenty-first century sailors themselves far from acceptable.
Initial jubilation at news the Allies would win the war is quickly doused by the chilling realization that the time travelers themselves--by their very presence--have rendered history null and void. Celebration turns to dread when the possibility arises that other elements of the twenty-first century task force may have also made the trip--and might now be aiding Yamamoto and the Japanese.
What happens next is anybody's guess--and everybody's nightmare. . . .
- Print length448 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- Publication date1 Jun. 2004
- Dimensions15.56 x 2.57 x 23.5 cm
- ISBN-100345457129
- ISBN-13978-0345457127
Frequently bought together

Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Product description
Review
"This book has everying: time travel, the British royalty, things that go boom, and unrelenting action. Read the opening at your own risk: you won't be doing anything else until you finish it."--Sean Williams, co-author of Heirs of Earth and Star Wars: Force Heretic: Reunion
From the Back Cover
a catastrophic event disrupts the course of World War II, forever changing the rules of combat. . . .
The impossible has spawned the unthinkable. A military experiment in the year 2021 has thrust an American-led multinational armada back to 1942, right into the middle of the U.S. naval task force speeding toward Midway Atoll--and what was to be the most spectacular U.S. triumph of the entire war.
Thousands died in the chaos, but the ripples had only begun. For these veterans of Pearl Harbor--led by Admirals Nimitz, Halsey, and Spruance--have never seen a helicopter, or a satellite link, or a nuclear weapon. And they've never encountered an African American colonel or a British naval commander who was a woman "and half-Pakistani. While they embrace the armada's awesome firepower, they may find the twenty-first century sailors themselves far from acceptable.
Initial jubilation at news the Allies would win the war is quickly doused by the chilling realization that the time travelers themselves--by their very presence--have rendered history null and void. Celebration turns to dread when the possibility arises that other elements of the twenty-first century task force may have also made the trip--and might now be aiding Yamamoto and the Japanese.
What happens next is anybody's guess--and everybody's nightmare. . . .
About the Author
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
East Timor, Zone Time: 0942 Hours, 15 January 2021
The Calihate spy, a Javanese carpenter known simply as Adil, resettled himself against a comfortable groove in the sandalwood tree. The small, shaded clearing in the hills overlooking Dili had been his home for three days. He shared it with an aged feral cat, which remained hidden throughout the day, and an irritable monkey, which occasionally tried to shit on his head. He had considered shooting the filthy animal, but his orders were explicit. He was to remain unnoticed as long as the crusaders were anchored off East Timor, observing their fleet and sending reports via microburst laser link, but only in the event of a "significant development."
He had seen nothing "significant" in seventy-two hours. The infidel ships were lying so far offshore they were often lost in haze and distance. Only when night fell did he have any real chance of seeing them, and even then they remained little more than a blurred constellation of twinkling, faraway lights. Such was their arrogance they didn't bother to cloak themselves in darkness.
Jets roared to and from the flight deck of their carrier twenty-four hours a day. In deepest night the fire of the launches appeared to Adil as though God Himself had lit a torch on the rim of the world.
Occasionally a helicopter would appear from the direction of the flotilla, beginning as a small, indistinct dot in the hot gray sky, taking on recognizable form only as the muffled drone of its engines clarified into a thudding, growling roar. From his hiding spot Adil could almost make out the faces of the infidels in the cabins of the fat metal birds. American, British, French, they all looked alike, cruel and overfed, a thought that reminded him of his own hunger.
He unwrapped the banana leaves from around a small rice cake, thanking Allah for the generosity of his masters. They had included a little dried fish in his rations for today, a rare treat.
Sometimes, when the sun climbed directly overhead and beat down with a slow fury, Adil's thoughts wandered. He cursed his weakness and begged God for the strength to carry out his duty, but it was hard. He had fallen asleep more than once. Nothing ever seemed to happen. There was plenty of movement down in Dili, which was infested with crusader forces from all over the Christian world, but Dili wasn't his concern. His sole responsibility was to watch those ships that were hiding in the shimmering haze on the far horizon.
Still, Adil mused, it would be nice to know he had some real purpose here; that he had not been staked out like a goat on the side of a hill. Perhaps he was to be part of some elaborate strike on the Christians in town. Perhaps tonight the darkness would be torn asunder by holy fire as some martyr blew up one of their filthy taverns. But then, why leave him here on the side of this stupid hill, covered in monkey shit and tormented by ants?
This wasn't how he had imagined jihad would be when he had graduated from the Madrasa in Bandung.
USS Kandahar, 1014 Hours, 15 January 2021
The marines wouldn't have been surprised at all to discover that someone like Adil was watching over them. In fact, they assumed there were more than two hundred million pairs of eyes turned their way as they prepared to deploy into the Indonesian Archipelago.
Nobody called it the Caliphate. Officially the United States still recognized it as the sovereign territory of Indonesia, seventeen thousand islands stretching from Banda Aceh, three hundred kilometers off the coast of Thailand, down to Timor, just north of Australia. The sea-lanes passing through those islands carried a third of the world's maritime trade, and officially they remained open to all traffic. The Indonesian government-in-exile said so-from the safety of the Grand Hyatt in Geneva where they had fled, three weeks earlier, after losing control of Jakarta.
Unofficially though, these were the badlands, controlled-just barely-by a revolutionary Islamic government calling itself the Caliphate and laying claim to all seventeen thousand islands, as well as the territory of Malaysia, the Philippines, Brunei, East Timor, Papua New Guinea, Bougainville, and, for good measure, northern Australia. Nonbelievers were not welcome. The spiritual leader of the Caliphate, Mullah Ibn Abbas, had proclaimed this as the will of Allah.
The Eighty-second Marine Expeditionary Unit begged to differ. And on the hangar deck of the USS Kandahar, a Baghdad-class littoral assault ship, they were preparing a full and frank rebuttal.
The hangar was a vast, echoing space. Two full decks high and running nearly a third of the length of the slab-sided vessel, it still seemed crowded, packed tight with most of the Eighty-second's air wing-a small air force in its own right consisting of a dozen Ospreys, four aging Super Stallions, two reconditioned command Hueys, eight Sea Comanche gunships, and half a dozen Super Harriers.
The Harriers and Super Stallions had been moved onto the "roof"-the flight deck, thus allowing the ground combat element of the Eighty-second MEU to colonize the space that had been opened up. The GCE was formally known as the Third Battalion of the Ninth Regiment, Fifth Marine Division. It was also known as the Lonesome Dead, after their passably famous CO, Colonel J. Lonesome Jones.
Not all of 3 Batt were embarked upon the Kandahar. The battalion topped out at more than twelve hundred men and women, and some of their number had to be berthed elsewhere in the three ships that were carry-
ing the Eighty-second into harm's way. The USS Providence, a Harper's Ferry-class amphibious landing dockship (LSD), took the battalion's four Abrams tanks, a rifle company, and the amphibious assault vehicle platoon. The Kennebunkport, a venerable LPD 12, carried the recon platoon, the regiment's Humvees, two more Hueys, the drone platoon, and the Navy SEAL team that would be providing security to the Eighty-second during their cruise through the archipelago.
Even as Adil unwrapped his rice cake and squinted into the blue expanse of the Wetar Strait a six-man detachment from the SEAL team was unpacking their gear on the hangar deck of the Kandahar, where they were getting set to train the men of C Company, 3 Batt.
Charlie Company doubled as Colonel Jones's cliff assault and small boat raiding squadron, and the SEALs had come to acquaint them with a new toy: the G4, a lightweight assault rifle that fired strips of caseless ceramic ammunition and programmable 30mm grenades. It was to become standard equipment throughout the U.S. armed forces within twelve months. The marines, however, were always at the bottom of the food chain, and would probably have waited two years before they laid hands on these toys. But the battalion logistics officer, Lieutenant Colonel Nancy Viviani, was an inventive and talented S4. As always, Viviani was determined that the battalion should have the very best equipment other people's money could buy.
Not that long ago she would have been known as a scavenger, a scrounger, and would have done her job under the cover of darkness with a pair of wire cutters and a fast getaway jeep. She would have been a man, too, of course. But Lieutenant Colonel Viviani carried two master's degrees into combat, one of them an MBA from the London School of Economics, and the graduates of that august institution didn't stoop to anything so crude as petty theft. Not when they could play the Pentagon's fantastically complex supply programs like an antique violin.
Six and a half hours of extracurricular keyboard time had been enough to release a shipment of G4s from pre-positioned supply vessels in Darwin. Viviani's genius was in making the process appear entirely legitimate. Had the Senate Armed Forces Committee itself spent a year inspecting her electronic audit trail, it would have found everything in order with absolutely nothing linking the G4 shipment to the loss of a similar supply package scheduled for delivery to an army public relations unit.
"This is the Remington G-four," CPO Vincente Rogas barked at the members of C Company. "By the end of today's lecture you will be familiar with the procedure for maintaining this weapon in the field." It sounded more like a threat than a promise.
"The G-four is the first solid-state infantry weapon," he bellowed. "It has very few moving parts."
A slight murmur passed through the tight knot of marines. They were familiar with the weapons specs, having intensively trained with them back in the United States. But still, it was a hell of a thing to wrap your head around.
"And this is the standard battle load." His audience stared at the long thin strip of ceramic munitions like children at their first magic show. "The ammo strip is placed in the barrel like this. An electrical charge ignites the propellant casing, driving the slug out with such velocity that, even with a three-round burst, you will feel no kickback-at least not before the volley leaves the muzzle.
"Tomorrow, when we move ashore to the range, each of you will be allotted three hundred rounds. I suggest very strongly that before then you take advantage of the full VR tutorial we've loaded into your training sets. The base software package is a standard Asian urban conflict scenario, but we've added modules specifically tailored for operations in Jakarta and Surabaya."
With deployment less than a fortnight away, similar scenes were being replayed throughout the U.S.-led Multinational Force accompanying the Kandahar. Twelve thousand very serious men and women drilled to the point of exhaustion. They were authorized by the UN Security Council to use whatever force was necessary to reestablish control of the capital, Jakarta, and to put an end to the mass murder of Indonesia's Chinese and Christian minorities. Everybody was preparing for a slaughter.
In the hundred-bed hospital of the Kandahar the Eighty-second's chief combat surgeon, Captain Margie Francois, supervised her team's reaction to a simulated missile strike on an armored hovercraft carrying a marine rifle company into a contested estuary.
Two thousand meters away, the French missile frigate Dessaix dueled with a pair of Raptors off the supercarrier USS Hillary Clinton.
In the other direction, three thousand meters to the west, two British trimaran stealth destroyers practiced their response to a successful strike by suicide bombers whose weapon of choice had been a high-speed rubber boat. Indeed, Captain Karen Halabi, who had been on the receiving end of just such an attack as a young ensign, drilled the crew of the HMS Trident so fiercely that in those few hours they were allowed to sleep, most dreamed of crazy men in speedboats laden with TNT.
JRV Nagoya, 1046 Hours, 15 January 2021
As diverse as these ships were, one still stood out. The Joint Research Vessel Nagoya was a purpose-built leviathan, constructed around the frame of an eighty-thousand-tonne liquid natural gas carrier. Her keel had been laid down in Korea, with the fit-out split between San Francisco and Tokyo, reflecting the multinational nature of her funding. She fit in with the sleek warships of the Multinational Force the way a hippo would with a school of swordfish.
Her presence was a function of the speed with which the crisis in Jakarta had developed. The USS Leyte Gulf, a stealth cruiser from the Clinton's battle group, had been riding shotgun over the Nagoya's sea trials in the benign waters off Western Australia. When the orders came down that the carrier and her battle group were to move immediately into the Wetar Strait the Nagoya had been left with no choice but to tag along until an escort could be assigned to shepherd her safely back to Hawaii. It was a situation nobody liked, least of all Professor Manning Pope, the leader of the Nagoya team.
Crouched over a console in his private quarters, Pope muttered under his breath as he hammered out yet another enraged e-mail directly to Admiral Tony Kevin, commander in chief, U.S. Pacific Command. It was the ninth such e-mail he had sent in forty-eight hours. Each had elicited a standardized reply, not from the admiral himself mind you, but from some trained monkey on his personal staff.
Pope typed, stabbing at the keys:
Need I remind you of the support this Project elicits at THE VERY HIGHEST LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT. I would not wish to be in your shoes, Admiral Kevin, when I explain to your superiors that we have gone over budget while being dragged into this pointless fiasco. The NAGOYA is a research vessel, not a warship, and we should have been allowed to continue our trials unmolested in the perfectly safe testing range off Perth. As small as they are, the Australian navy are more than capable of fending off any drunken fishermen who might have strayed too close.
Therefore I DEMAND that we be freed from this two-penny opera and allowed to return to our test schedule as originally planned. I await your earliest reply. And that means YOURS, Admiral Kevin. Not some junior baboon!
That'll put a rocket under his fat ass, thought Pope. Bureaucrats hate it when you threaten to go over their heads. It means they might actually have to stagger to their feet and do something for a change.
Spleen vented for the moment, he keyed into the vidlink that connected him with the Project control room. A Japanese man with a shock of unruly, thick black hair answered the hail.
"How do we look for a power-up this morning, Yoshi?" Pope asked. "I'm anxious to get back on schedule."
Standing at a long, curving bank of flatscreens Professor Yoshi Murayama, an unusually tall cosmic string theorist from Honshu, blew out his cheeks and shrugged. "I can't see why not from this end. We're just about finished entering the new data sets. We're good to go, except you know that Kolhammer won't like it."
"Kolhammer's a chickenshit," Pope said somewhat mournfully. "I really don't care what he thinks. He's not qualified to tell us what we can and cannot do. You are."
"Like I said," the Japanese Nobel winner responded. "I don't see a problem. Just a beautiful set of numbers."
"Of course." Pope nodded. "Everyone else feel the same?" he asked, raising his voice so that it projected into the room beyond Murayama. The space was surprisingly small for such a momentous undertaking, no bigger than a suburban living room really. Large glowing monitors shared the area with half a dozen senior Project researchers, each staffing a workstation.
His question caught them off-guard. Their boss enjoyed a hard-won reputation as a thoroughly unpleasant little prick with an amazingly rigid pole up his ass. A couple of them exchanged quick glances, but nobody said anything for a few moments until Barnes, their magnetic ram technician, ventured a reply.
"Well, it's not our fault we fell behind. But you can bet we'll get blamed if we don't hustle to catch up."
"Exactly!" Pope replied. "Let's prepare for a test run at point-zero-one efficiency. That should be enough to confirm a stabilized effect with the new figures. Are we all agreed?"
Product details
- Publisher : Del Rey Books
- Publication date : 1 Jun. 2004
- Language : English
- Print length : 448 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0345457129
- ISBN-13 : 978-0345457127
- Item weight : 454 g
- Dimensions : 15.56 x 2.57 x 23.5 cm
- Book 1 of 5 : Axis of Time
- Best Sellers Rank: 1,461,798 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- 1,957 in Science Fiction Alternate History
- 5,068 in War Story Fiction
- 7,350 in Science Fiction Adventure (Books)
- Customer reviews:
About the author

Hey there. It's me. JB. Right now I'm probably kicking back on my hovercraft somewhere in the Antilles, or the Maldives, enjoying a dissolute, essentially meaningless life funded by your generous book purchases. Please, don't make me go back to selling my bodily fluids to science. Buy my books now and I promise to keep indulging myself in grotesque pleasures and luxury that I haven't really earned.
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings, help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the book action-packed and well-written, describing it as a page-turner with an epic journey. They appreciate its depth, with one customer noting it's well thought out from a linear perspective, and find it fun to read. However, the character development receives negative feedback from multiple customers.
AI Generated from the text of customer reviews
Customers enjoy the action-packed story of this alternative history science fiction book, with one customer noting it's the best blend of sci-fi and WW2 action.
"fantastic story" Read more
"...book, and in terms of the ideas explored in across it's pages, fascinating...." Read more
"...This is the best blending of sci-fi and WW2 action since Neal Stephenson’s Cryptonomicon...." Read more
"...is a master of writing about battle but in this book he maintains a tension, if not just above the surface then hovering just below - even when..." Read more
Customers find the book absolutely terrific and really great to read.
"...Birmingham is a great writer. His characters are flawed, but likeable, three-dimensional entities...." Read more
"Absolutly terrific - I couldnot wait to purchase the 2nd book in the seris of 3...." Read more
"Interesting premise that was a good read." Read more
"A page turner but ultimately a pretty terrible book...." Read more
Customers praise the writing quality of the book, describing it as a page-turner, with one customer noting its excellent blend of fact and fiction.
"...Beyond that however, this is a very well written book, and in terms of the ideas explored in across it's pages, fascinating...." Read more
"...Birmingham is a great writer. His characters are flawed, but likeable, three-dimensional entities...." Read more
"...Birmingham is a master of writing about battle but in this book he maintains a tension, if not just above the surface then hovering just below -..." Read more
"...Well written certainly, just a bit too war oriented for my tastes and very little time travel content after the explanation for the 'glitch' that..." Read more
Customers appreciate the depth of the book, finding it well thought out, with one customer noting it has oodles of potential for the author to explore.
"...This book doesn't. It shows us it all, the heroism and the racism and the sexism, the heroes, the lunatics, the geniuses, and the... well, bastards...." Read more
"...But this takes that basic idea and goes a whole lot deeper...." Read more
"...Suddenly, chaos and confusion - too much confusion - we need a clearer picture of what is happening but those few seconds are dragged out... so much..." Read more
"...easy to read romp with a fascinating concept and oodles of potential for the author to explore, and I am looking forward to seeing how they develop..." Read more
Customers find the book entertaining.
"...based around a very interesting idea which for the most part was enjoyably explored...." Read more
"...in many areas, but overreaches in others and whilst it's an engaging ride, questions arise throughout that aren't really answered at book's end...." Read more
"All sorts of fun..." Read more
"Fun and good..." Read more
Customers criticize the lack of character development in the book.
"...Birmingham is a great writer. His characters are flawed, but likeable, three-dimensional entities...." Read more
"...No character development I just couldn't get into the story. I didn't care what happened to any of the characters and it lacked any real depth...." Read more
"...Found it to be flat and 1 dimensional and lacked any real character and plot depth!..." Read more
Top reviews from United Kingdom
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 23 November 2012...for a whole host of reasons. I'll be honest, I bought this having read about it on TV Tropes, and I think the line which sold me on it was 'time traveling, SAS Prince Harry'. Well you certainly get that!
Beyond that however, this is a very well written book, and in terms of the ideas explored in across it's pages, fascinating. It does show it's age somewhat (like most books set 20 minutes into the future tbh), but even so it gives us a somewhat chilling vision of a world of 2021 as if the War on Terror had actually extended into an all up war that had rumbled on for decades (along with the consequences of such warfare on the world's militaries and the continuance of social trends of today), then goes ahead and juxtaposes that brutally with the martial and popular culture of the 1940s. Could have gone so wrong, so easily, yet it works brilliantly.
Which leads me onto the other thing about this book (and it's sequels for that matter): it gives us a very close look at the social attitudes of the 1940s and the heroes of WW2. All too often, literature (and just about every form of media) tends to look back on that time as a golden age, where for the Allies, all was noble and grand, and where the figures were genuine all-round heroes of legend, whilst for the Axis, all was oppressive and evil, and all of their soldiers and scientists and leaders were utterly inhuman monsters. This book doesn't. It shows us it all, the heroism and the racism and the sexism, the heroes, the lunatics, the geniuses, and the... well, bastards. Even more refreshingly, it does that for both the Allied and Axis powers, and doesn't pull any punches for either of them.
And yet along with all of that, it still manages to retain a sense of humour (such as that wonderful moment involving FDR, Eisenhower and a comment about how since he wasn't president yet, Eisenhower still had to work for a living), and despite the introspection, the action sequences are some of the best I've ever read.
So, all told, this book it very much recommended.
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 1 November 2019This is not so much a review of this one book so much as a review of the whole series.
That’s because I bought this first one and enjoyed it so much I immediately got the next two books in the series.
Now, in essence this is a goofy idea. It was explored in the thoroughly ridiculous 1980 movie The Final Countdown .
But this takes that basic idea and goes a whole lot deeper. The examination of culture clashes between the 21st-Century military and their 1940s counterparts are at least as important as the kickass action sequences.
And, let me tell you, the kickass action sequences are most definitely worth the price of admission.
Birmingham is a great writer. His characters are flawed, but likeable, three-dimensional entities. Maybe a bit more durable than real-life people but that’s adventure stories for you.
Couple of minor quibbles:
The ‘future tech’ the writer imagined for 2021 in 2004 is, for the most part, still not yet realised but maybe in 2031 it will be.
The 2nd book is definitely the weakest of the series. But it’s worth getting because it sets up the amazing third entry in the trilogy.
But, that said, even the second book has some seriously fun moments.
This is the best blending of sci-fi and WW2 action since Neal Stephenson’s Cryptonomicon. And I absolutely do not make that comparison lightly.
This is a lot of fun. Check it out.
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 26 April 2014Like a movie, the book opens with a countdown concentrating on the bevy of characters that will make up the core of the story. Suddenly, chaos and confusion - too much confusion - we need a clearer picture of what is happening but those few seconds are dragged out... so much is happening...
Boom! mayhem... chaos. Two fleets from opposite ends of time clash! Slowly, out of the noise and light and murder and confusion of battle things calm down as men and officers begin to take control.
I'm 200 pages in and never noticed...
I'm halfway through and I feel like I've been dosed up with some sort of high octane drug... I can't put it down!!
A clash of fleets but a clash of cultures also. The past is another world, alien, unrecognisable because our own attitudes, everything we take for granted, haven't begun to evolve yet...
Birmingham does something here I've never come across before and I think it shows a depth of perception that has to be applauded. It would be very difficult to deal with this issue in straightforward literature - you need a medium like SF (where anything can happen and any issue can become the chief focus). It's not long before the dangers posed by this alien past become a genuine concern for those who have been thrust - and stranded - there.
Birmingham is a master of writing about battle but in this book he maintains a tension, if not just above the surface then hovering just below - even when things have calmed down. You want to be a page ahead all the time... what happens next... what happens next... what happens next....
This one comes HIGHLY recommended.
Top reviews from other countries
- AjReviewed in Canada on 13 May 2013
5.0 out of 5 stars I loved this book
I loved every thingabout this book. The story line was great and so was the concept. I would recommend this book
- McKinneyTexasReviewed in the United States on 7 November 2004
5.0 out of 5 stars Same Class as Stirling or Turtledove
The very few minor flaws in this otherwise outstanding first effort are simply evidence that no one writes a perfect novel. Alternative history/time travel is a great genre when done right, but more typically is the province of one dimensional, shallow character development coupled with whiz-bangers that require a total suspension of belief and rounded out by plot devices that combine outlandish good fortune and timing with little or no actual relationship to the story line. Not so here. The story flows, the characters are real and the author has his social/technical act together. And, as a bonus, the dialogue has regular moments of humor, cleverness, insight and pain.
WEAPONS OF CHOICE falls only a bit short in what the book calls the 'Transition', i.e. that actual temporal displacement itself. The deficiency is that more goes wrong--way wrong--than should be the case. It makes a certain amount of sense for the temporal displacement to have somewhat of a random and unfortunate impact on the time travelers. This is more than adequately captured, and in fact is overdone. The flaw lies in having the displaced fleet land smack dab in the middle of the June, 1942 U.S. Fleet en route to Midway to engage the Japanese invasion fleet. The Pacific Ocean is a damn big ocean and the transported Combined Fleet covered an area perhaps 25 miles in diameter. Its like trying to hit a quarter lying on a football field with another quarter and doing it from another dimension. Having the 1942 U.S. Fleet see and recognize just the lone Japanese Self-Defense Force ship that makes up a small part of the larger Combined Fleet compounds the flaw. This device results in immediate shooting between the two fleets, with the primitive 1942 Fleet giving a pretty good account of itself. Another of the Combined Fleet is split longitudinally, apparently to demonstrate the finite limits of the temporal displacement while yet another is molecularly blended with one of the contemporary U.S. Fleet. Too much of a bad thing, if you ask me.
Although flawed in this respect, even this part of the book and the balance are extremely well done and it is a fun read. Other reviewers have noted the references to other AH greats, Stirling and Flint and also to Turtledove's World War series. I'll be the first to note that the references to space lizards by President Roosevelt is directed to Cmdr. Turtletaub, Harry Turtledove's precurser name.
Best of all is the blending of cultures, socially, militarily and technologically. Some reviewers are turned off by what they see as a liberal bent. My politics are at least as conservative as most Texans and probably more so. Too bad the ideological blinders we see today on the hard Left are just as prevalent on the hard Right. The fact is, mid-century America was great if you were white and had a job, otherwise, it had its shortcomings. Putting a Mexican or a Black in a superior position to white males back then was beyond the capacity of many, if not most Americans to comprehend, much less accept. This is doubly true for women, and particularly minority women. Face it fellow conservatives, it was this way, no getting around it. Having said that, the author would do well to remember that the armed forces were integrated in 1950 (or a year or two before)and Brown v. Board of Education was decided in 1954. The country was open, at least part of it, to change, although certainly not the level of we have today or are certain to see in 17 years. The times, they were a changin' and they still are.
These same reviewers are troubled that Hillary Clinton gets such favorable play. Have they followed her comments post 9-11? I will most likely never buy into most of her domestic agenda, but like Lieberman and Gephardt, and too few other prominent Democrats, she doesn't stutter in the least about the need to fight fundamentalist terrorism with everything we have. Like her or not, you wouldn't want her mad at you and I am pretty sure, as a senator from New York, she is not happy with the bad guys.
Now, for the book itself: Birmingham picks up with near perfection on not just the extension of military and social evolution the present day suggests, but he also--and you have to really like this in a time travel novel--describes with what seems to this technologically challenged history major/trial lawyer an entirely plausible (insofar as these things can be plausible) time travel mechanism. Worm holes, singularities, quantum foam--apparently these are words that esoteric physicists actually use. I recognize that they are in English, but that is as far as it goes. One thing for sure, even for scientific illiterates, it reads well.
Finally, for military history buffs, Birmingham has done his homework. If you ever wanted a great blending of near future with recent past in a military context this is it, bar none. Highly recommended and looking forward to the next two--too bad the ideologues can't lighten up.
- Carl PeetersReviewed in Australia on 26 July 2024
5.0 out of 5 stars Great story
Great story, very interestingly done
-
HolzwurmReviewed in Germany on 31 May 2007
5.0 out of 5 stars ein würdiger Tom Clancy-Nachfolger ..
Wenn man die zugegeben abenteuerliche Prämisse des Buches (Schlachtschiff-Verband aus dem 21. Jahrhundert wird aufgrund eines mißglückten Experiments in das Jahr 1942 versetzt) akzeptiert, ist die Axis of Time-Trilogie ein spannender Techno-Thriller, der angenehm an frühe Tom Clancy-Bücher erinnert. Der Twist, das Technologie aus dem 21. Jahrhundert beiden Kriegsparteien in die Hände fällt, mischt die Karten im 2. Weltkrieg völlig neu. Auch die Charaktere sind gut herausgearbeitet, und ein interessanter Subplot dreht sich um die alltäglichen Konflikte zwischen den konservativen Amerikanern der 40er Jahre und der multikulturellen, liberalen Crew aus dem 21. Jahrhundert. Der Humor kommt auch nicht zu kurz, sei verraten.
- T. M. StamlerReviewed in Canada on 25 November 2009
4.0 out of 5 stars Pretty Good, But He Should Have Stopped Here
Since there have already been several reviews about this book, I'll make this brief.
One of the things I love about alternate history is that you find out how little you really know about the original history. Birmingham definitely did his research here, and it made the story work well.
The characters are both interesting and likeable, even some of the more close-minded ones in their way, and their reactions to what they might have ended up becoming is also fascinating. That in mind, I kinda wish the author had spent more time on them and their reactions, instead of bouncing back and forth between our boys and girls from the future and the '42s (as the past folks end up being called).
And he ended the book well, too. You are just getting to the end, you have enjoyed it, but think, 'I think I'll skip on the other two books', when BAM! He ends the book with an unbelievable hook, and now you have to read the other two. I bought them, got about 100 pages into the second and lost interest. Mostly because, like I said, too much time was spent on the future guys and not enough on the past. I had just finished reading S.M Stirling's Nantucket series when I started this, and that one does focus more on the future people, but that story is set 3000 years in the past, where, or when, we have little to no information of what all was going on. In 1942, going on 70 years ago, we have all kinds of records, journals, reports and footage of what went on, so there's no reason more time couldn't have been spent on that era.
But that I didn't notice until the second book; like I said, if he had left it off with the first one, it woul've been an invigorating and eye-opening romp, with a great cliffhanger ending to boot, but unfortunately, everyone's gotta be making trilogies these days.