The Blue, Beautiful World
(Cygnus Beta Series #3)
By Karen Lord
Del Rey Books — August 2023
ISBN: 9780593598436 — Hardcover — 256 pp.
Depending on one’s point of view or reading personality, Karen Lord’s The Blue, Beautiful World could be considered a stand-alone novel within here Cygnus Beta universe of stories, or a more firmly-linked sequel of a series, following The Best of All Possible Worlds (2013) and The Galaxy Game (2015.) While the second and recent third novel of Cygnus Beta are fully comprehensible and enjoyable as isolated works, world-building elements, reappearing characters, and shared themes throughout the series would make each novel easier to unravel on their own and form an appreciation for connections between the parts of the overarching work.
I previously reviewed The Galaxy Game here with a similar overall conclusion, having never read the first Cygnus Beta novel. Looking back at it now, I’m reminded that I really do need to just read the entire series from the start. With some experience of Lord’s novels under my belt, I began The Blue, Beautiful World with more familiarity of what to expect in terms of Lord’s style. And I ended up being able to enjoy and appreciate it more than I had The Galaxy Game. Yet, I know I still haven’t been able to unpack all that there is in the novel or experience the pleasure of the plot’s progression as I likely would by starting at the beginning of the series. Additionally, I’ll note that I’ve now read both of Lord’s novels as ebooks, an experience I’ve found to interfere with my personal ability to engage with a work. Looking back on things I’ve read and reviewed, I find myself picking up on the writing and getting excited about a novel far more frequently with physical books than ebooks.
The ebook ARC version of The Blue, Beautiful World came to me in preparation for an interview with Karen Lord for the Skiffy & Fanty podcast. I obtained and read the novel on a relatively quick time line to be an alternate for the podcast recording, which ultimately Brandon O’Brien and Shaun Duke were able to do. That’s for the best, because they did a stellar job, taking part in a fascinating conversation with Lord about her latest novel and work as a whole. If you end up still being undecided on The Blue, Beautiful World – or starting off the series at its start – do give this interview a general listen. For those who may have already read the novel, there’s some good content to get you thinking more deeply about that experience.
OK – After all this preamble, what is The Blue, Beautiful World actually about and what is the nature of Karen Lord’s writing?
Human civilization continues Earth and the life upon it on a course of profound change, reaching ever closer to a tipping point where the collective, contradictory mix of activism, panic, and indifference will push things into a vastly different reality for better or worse. Adding complexity to this, humanoid life exists on planets orbiting stars relatively close to our Sol, and representatives of these are looking to make official first contact with Earth. Those on Earth remaining in power with knowledge of alien civilization existence and potential influence on Earth stand in tension with the varying goals and interests of those aliens for our planet.
The Blue, Beautiful World begins after a short prologue by introducing Owen, a pop music star whose charisma – and other abilities – command enormous attention and influence over his legions of worldwide fans. Though not explicitly stated, the reader can quickly make the connection of Owen to the exchanges of the prologue set on another planet. While the previous Cygnus Beta novels have been set off-Earth, this one remains on our planet, as its title suggests. Owen becomes involved with a group of similar celebrity influencers and visioneers seeking to prepare humanity for official first contact in all its implications and potential consequences. To say more of the plot would be complicated, and would be detrimental to the key component of Lord’s writing that demands readers to construct things from fragmentary revelation.
Like its predecessors, The Blue, Beautiful World deals with large scale epic events but on a largely intimate level of individual human/humanoid relationships. Also, like those prior entries, it’s an unconventional approach to the space opera genre that is built on suddenly shifting perspectives, focus, and twists of reader expectations. This could be immensely rewarding for certain kinds of readers, and exceptionally frustrating for others. Just as the reader starts becoming familiar with Owen and his wonderfully compelling manager Noriko, the first part of the novel ends and Lord abruptly shifts things in setting and characters, requiring readers to completely reset footing and figure out how what is happening and where connections lie. While focusing intently on the perspectives and interactions among the relatively large cast, Lord conveys many large scale developments to the overall plot briefly, almost as if in passing.
As Lord describes in her interview with Skiffy & Fanty in response to Shaun’s remark over how much The Blue, Beautiful World threw him for a loop, her writing style specifically aims to leave some things unsaid, some things unexplained, because that is how reality is. We’re all here struggling to figure out the universe, and our place it. Her characters and her novels are in that same place. Like us, they are trying to figure out if they are the protagonist of their story or if someone else is, she explains. As a result, Owen is kind of the protagonist of the novel, at least the first part – though maybe it’s more Noriko – then others join in vying for that role.
To summarize the significance of this for a perspective reader, The Blue Beautiful World is a well-written novel of complexity and intelligence, but it’s not a well-written space opera comfort read. It’s demanding. Lord writes beautifully, in that her sentences are rich and evocative, and they can be enjoyed at just that level. But if the reader just starts getting confused regarding the plot or thrown off by shifts in perspective, that beauty can only hold attention so long. But if the reader is down for careful reading, reflection, and appreciation of the novel’s realism, there are few other contenders out there to its power.
As opposed to my read of The Galaxy Game many years back, there were several elements to The Blue, Beautiful World that captured and held my interest even while wishing for a little more constancy and familiarity to keep my bearings. As with the other books of Cygnus Beta, this novel addresses the theme of power, of looking at who gets to make decisions for the planet and its inhabitants. It involves the politics of diplomacy more than I recall from the previous novel, and I enjoyed those threads, particuarly relevant to the first-contact trope of space opera. Adding into that mix, Lord includes a fantastic bit in here regarding how those with vested interest in our planet and intelligence to communicate so might extend beyond the human. With nation-state political powers collapsing and shifting amid the changes to Earth, many of those with historic powers begin to see that influence and control slipping away, with more going out to common citizens who manage to gain attention and influence of the population providing them with the opportunities and responsibilities of celebrity.
Being from the island of Barbados, Lord offers a unique and needed voice to the space opera genre with the Cygnus Beta novels that show how various voices, cultures, and politics come together into interesting possibilities for the future. In some ways the novels are a literary manifestation of that identity of relatively small nation, an intimate population isolated by surrounding sea-space yet firmly connected with a global network.
I’m now eager to finally get that physical copy of The Best of All Possible Worlds and more fully diving into Lord’s work for what I might have missed about it, myself, and this blue orb we live upon.